Historian Defends Dick Cheney’s Legacy Amid Post-9/11 Controversies

Conservative historian Craig Shirley asserted on Sunday that former Vice President Dick Cheney should be remembered for his lifetime contributions rather than solely for his role in the Iraq War. Shirley emphasized that Cheney’s decisions, though controversial, were driven by what he believed was the best interest of America during a time of heightened national fear following the 9/11 attacks.

Shirley argued that Cheney’s legacy must be evaluated through the “totality of his life” rather than “presentism,” or judging past actions by modern standards. He highlighted the climate of uncertainty in post-9/11 America, where the public anticipated further terrorist threats, leading to difficult and sometimes flawed decisions.

The historian recounted interviews with Cheney during his research on former Presidents Ronald Reagan and House Speaker Newt Gingrich, describing him as “a good and decent man.” Shirley also noted the evolving role of the vice presidency, citing historical examples such as Richard Johnson’s disinterest in the position under Martin Van Buren and John Nance Garner’s dismissive remark about its value. He pointed to Walter Mondale’s 1976 tenure as a turning point, marking the first time the vice president held significant executive influence within the White House.

Shirley acknowledged that increased power brings risks but stressed that Cheney’s motivations were rooted in his belief in national security during a perilous era.