Immigration Judges Firing Sparks Controversy Stella Green, December 2, 2025 The Trump administration has recently sparked significant debate following reports of eight immigration judges being dismissed, according to an analysis by Brian Freeman on Tuesday. This action comes after a former immigration judge named Tania Nemer filed a lawsuit alleging unlawful discrimination. Her case centers specifically around her termination shortly after starting work despite receiving high performance reviews. Nemer’s allegations detail that she was abruptly fired due to factors including her gender and Lebanese citizenship, which are said to violate civil rights protections. The National Association of Immigration Judges has noted broader concerns about job stability within the Department of Justice under this administration. They’ve observed a number of judges either resigning or being let go, representing what they perceive as an effort by officials in government efficiency departments to reduce spending through personnel adjustments. Interestingly, after her termination, Nemer took direct action by lodging a formal discrimination complaint with Equal Employment Opportunity authorities within the department itself. However, these offices reportedly dismissed her claim initially before any legal challenge was filed. The Department of Justice’s position counters such assertions, maintaining that administrators possess full authority to dismiss employees and that terminating Nemer constituted a lawful exercise of this power. Brian Freeman, based in Israel, contributes cultural and political analysis with more than three decades of experience covering newspapers, online platforms, and television networks for outlets like Newsmax. Politics