Mamdani’s Victory Speech Ignites Controversy Amid Concerns Over Socialist Platform Stella Green, December 1, 2025 NEW YORK – On election night, Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani delivered a victory speech that drew sharp criticism from political observers. George J. Marlin, author of “The American Catholic Voter: Two Hundred Years of Political Impact,” described the address as “the most disdainful [he’d] ever heard.” Marlin noted how the mayor-elect’s typically cheerful demeanor transformed into something more abrasive. He quoted Mamdani’s dismissive tone towards his main opponent, former Governor Andrew Cuomo, and pointed to a particularly inflammatory closing statement: “…I refuse to apologize for any of this.” The remarks were seen as arrogant by many political analysts. Beyond the speech itself, concerns have grown over Mamdani’s proposed socialist policies. His administration will face an immediate operating budget deficit of approximately $8 billion. Plans include raising the city corporate income tax rate from 7.25% to 11.55%, pushing the combined state and local rate significantly higher. Critics also voiced alarm about key appointments: – Chief-of-staff Elle Biscard-Church, a former pro-Palestine activist, is enthusiastic about establishing a “Department of Public Safety” that would employ social workers for domestic violence calls. – Deputy mayor Dean Fuleihan was seen as closely tied to de Blasio’s controversial policies during the pandemic. – Political director Hassaan Chaudhary has been criticized for his harsh comments regarding Israel and praise for Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. These appointments have sparked concern about the direction New York City may take under its new leadership. Opinion